• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to The Sandwich Mafia

The Sandwich Mafia, located in Estes Park, CO, offers a unique Italian-inspired menu with a focus on delicious sandwiches. With options like Alicia's Chicken Pesto Panini and Jimmy Conway sandwich, made with high-quality ingredients like fresh baked bread and flavorful pesto, customers are sure to be satisfied. The cozy deli setting with limited seating makes it perfect for a quick grab-and-go meal. The friendly staff and fast service at The Sandwich Mafia make it a must-visit spot for anyone craving a tasty post-hike sandwich experience.

The Sandwich Mafia: Reviews & Ratings

Cindy L.
Cindy L.

Alicia's Chicken Pesto Panini 3 sourdough, bacon, mozzarella Johnny Roast Beef Panini 4 foccacia bread (baked w/ cheese), enough roast beef, provolone, lettuce, tomato, sour pepperoncini (pickled yellow chili pepper), raw onions, bacon, pesto, flavorful

Samyukta S.
Samyukta S.

Stopped by The Sandwich Mafia for a quick lunch after a day of hiking in Rocky Mountain National Park. I was ravenous and in need of some carbs, and this place fit the bill. I ordered the Jimmy Conway sandwich - a classic turkey on wheat with Monterey Jack cheese and the usual fixings. It was delicious and I devoured it within minutes. It was clear that the bread was baked fresh in-house, the meat was of high quality and the vegetables had a nice crunch to them. Limited seating - this place is small and better for grab and go, but they do have some tables upstairs.

Shahan A.
Shahan A.

Chicken pesto was good. Nice deli w outside seating too. Only one bathroom though, so had to wait a few mins.

Annie L.
Annie L.

This place was the perfect post hike sandwich spot to fulfill our cravings. The pesto sandwich was amazing, service was fast and staff was kind and helpful, and we were the only ones there! It was laid back and comfortable.

Michelle A.
Michelle A.

When we walked in there was no line and right away we were greeted. You order your food fast casual and they bring it to you once you pay. The place has an upper level with tables that you can eat at and there are some condiments on the side. The place is cool with different pictures of mafia mobs. We got the pesto sandwich and the French dip and the pesto sandwich was our favorite!

Anthony C.
Anthony C.

This place has a fantastic location. As you walk down Elkhorn Ave, you'll notice a cool little sign at the start of an alleyway that says "Pizza." You'll also find a sign that points you through the alleyway and a menu. I give them credit for including the menu there as well; it makes it easier to decide to eat there without any pressure. Once you reach the end of the alley, you'll see the entrance. There is a second floor with seating and a bathroom, but you'll order downstairs. I will say, there isn't much seating, however, this place is more of a quick lunch before heading back to your stroll. The service was excellent - friendly and fast. The food came out fairly quickly. We ordered a pepperoni pizza, and something about their dough just tasted great. In my opinion, it was a very good pizza. We definitely enjoyed what this place had to offer. The unique location and delicious pizza make it a must-try!

Location

Introducing the hidden gem of Estes Park, CO, The Sandwich Mafia. This Italian sandwich joint has been garnering rave reviews from customers for its flavorful creations and cozy atmosphere. Located at 100 Cleave Street, this spot is a must-visit for sandwich aficionados looking for a unique dining experience.

Customers have been singing praises about the mouthwatering sandwiches at The Sandwich Mafia. From Alicia's Chicken Pesto Panini to the Johnny Roast Beef Panini, each sandwich is packed with fresh ingredients and bursting with flavor. The focus on quality shines through in every bite, making it a top choice for a satisfying meal.

One of the standout dishes mentioned by patrons is the Jimmy Conway sandwich. This classic turkey sandwich on wheat with Monterey Jack cheese and fresh fixings has left customers raving about the in-house baked bread and high-quality meats. The limited seating adds to the charm of this grab-and-go spot, perfect for a quick bite after a day of exploring Rocky Mountain National Park.

Not only is the food at The Sandwich Mafia top-notch, but the service and ambiance have also received high praise. With fast and friendly service, welcoming staff, and a laid-back atmosphere, it's no wonder customers keep coming back for more.

So if you find yourself in Estes Park craving a delicious sandwich, be sure to make a stop at The Sandwich Mafia. With its delectable menu, cozy setting, and exceptional customer reviews, this eatery is sure to satisfy your hunger and leave you wanting more.